Keycloak: Authenticator - Restrict user authentication on client

This is a simple Keycloak authenticator to restrict user authentication to client.

What is it good for?

Every now and then I get asked whether it is possible to restrict user authentication for certain clients.

Generally the question goes like this

Is it possible to allow specific users to authenticate to a client, while reject others?

As of today, my general answer is "no, at least not out of the box". And in general my advice is to redesign and relocate the policy enforcement point (PEP). However, since this question popped up so often, I wrote this simple authenticator to support this functionality.

Why not use "Allow/Deny Access" authenticators with conditions?

With Keycloak 13 two new authenticators have been added, namely Allow Access and Deny Access. Together with Condition - User Role authenticator authentication may be restricted in a similar way with out-of-the-box features. So, the question is why not use that and override authentication flows on a per client basis?

Here are some reasons/thoughts

• It is not really flexible. Since Condition - User Role only allows for checking one concrete (realm or client-specific) role, a very complex flow handling all clients, or a totally separate flow for each individual client would be needed.
• It simply does not work well with federated authentication (ie. identity provider redirects), since there is no way to configure client specific behaviour for First login flow or Post login flows. In other words, there is no feature like Authentication flow overrides at an IdP level. Hence, the same flow will be used for all clients. As said before, this becomes very complicated.

How does it work?

The authenticator uses client roles to restrict authentication. It works like this:

• The authenticator checks whether a client defines a role named restricted-access
  • If it does the authenticator checks whether the user has that role
    • If it does, the authenticator returns success (i.e. authentication is successful)
    • If it does not, the authenticator returns failure (i.e. authentication is unsuccessful)
  • If it does not, the authenticator returns success (i.e. authentication is successful).

This means that you can enable the feature by adding a client role to your client named restricted-access. A client with that role has the feature enabled. Only users with that role can authenticate to that client.

How to install?

Kecloak distribution powered by Wildfly

Download a release (*.jar file) that works with your Keycloak version from the list of releases.

Create a Wildfly module and deploy it to your Keycloak instance. For details please refer to the official documentation.

For convenience, here is a module.xml file.

<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<module xmlns="urn:jboss:module:1.3" name="keycloak-restrict-client-auth">
    <resources>
        <resource-root path="keycloak-restrict-client-auth.jar"/>
    </resources>
    <dependencies>
        <module name="org.keycloak.keycloak-services"/>
    </dependencies>
</module>

Container image (Docker)

For Docker-based setups mount or copy the jar to /opt/jboss/keycloak/providers. You may want to check docker-compose.yml as example.

Maven/Gradle

Packages are being released to GitHub Packages. You find the coordinates here! It may happen that I remove older packages without prior notice, because the storage is limited on the free tier.

How to configure?

Configuring the authenticator

1. First, you need to add the authenticator to your desired flow. Mark the authenticator as Required. Then bind your newly created flow as desired - either as a default for the whole realm or on a per-client basis. See the image below for an example.
2. Second, configure the authenticator by clicking on Actions -> Config and select restrict-client-auth-access-client-role as the Access Provider.
3. Third, you need to add a role named restricted-access to the client you want to restrict access to. See the image below for an example.
4. Afterwards, no user can authenticate to this client. To allow a user to authenticate, you need to assign the role restricted-access to the user. You may do so either by assigning the role to the user directly or via groups or combined roles.

⚠️ User identity:

The authenticator needs a user identity to check whether the user has the desired role or not. Hence, ensure that you have steps/executions in your flow prior to this authenticator that can ensure user's identity.

Using a custom error message

If a user tries to log in via a browser-based flow and access gets denied by the authenticator, a custom error message can be displayed. In the flow choose the Actions button and then choose Config. You will see the following configuration screen.

You can directly define a particular message or use a property, which will be used for mapping the error message. If you choose a property, the property will be looked up from your custom theme's messages*.properties files and therefore supports internationalization.

# messages.properties
restricted-access.denied=Access denied. User is missing required role 'restricted-access'
# messages_de.properties
restricted-access.denied=Zugriff verweigert. Dem Benutzer fehlt die notwendige Rolle 'restricted-access'.

If the field is blank, default property access-denied is used. In this case you do not need a custom theme, since this property comes with Keycloak out of the box. For details on how to add custom messages to Keycloak, please refer to Messages and Internationalization in the server developer guide.

Changing the default role name

You do not like the role name or you do have some kind of naming conventions in place? You can change the role name globally by configuring the provider.

via CLI:

/subsystem=keycloak-server/spi=restrict-client-auth-access-provider:add(default-provider=restrict-client-auth-access-client-role)
/subsystem=keycloak-server/spi=restrict-client-auth-access-provider/provider=restrict-client-auth-access-client-role:add(properties={clientRoleName=my-custom-role-name,enabled=true})

via standalone.xml:

<spi name="restrict-client-auth-access-provider">
    <default-provider>restrict-client-auth-access-client-role</default-provider>
    <provider name="restrict-client-auth-access-client-role" enabled="true">
        <properties>
            <property name="clientRoleName" value="my-custom-role-name"/>
        </properties>
    </provider>
</spi>

For details, please refer to Manage Subsystem Configuration section in the server installation guide.

Does it work with Keycloak version X.Y.Z?

If you are using Keycloak version X (e.g. X.y.z), version X.b.c should be compatible. Keycloak SPIs are quite stable. So, there is a high chance this authenticator will work with other versions, too. Check the details of latest build results for an overview or simply give it a try.

Authenticator version X.b.c is compiled against Keycloak version X.y.z. For example, version 12.3.1 will be compiled against Keycloak version 12.y.z.

I do not guarantee what version a.b or y.z will be. Neither do I backport features to older version, nor maintain any older versions of this authenticator. If you need the latest features or bugfixes for an older version, please fork this project or update your Keycloak instance. I recommend doing the latter on regular basis anyways.